Yes, I Am a Furry holds a 4.3 out of 5 on itch.io from 503 ratings, with 689 comments on the page. The same figure appears on the Game OFF 2025 and Game Jam Plus 2526 jam entries, since all three point at one submission. This is an itch star rating, not a Steam review percentage — there is no Steam version and no Steam review aggregate exists.
Whether the game has an ending is the most asked-about and least answered question in its comment section. Players have repeatedly asked whether there is a good ending, a bad ending, or any ending at all, and the developer did not address it in the 0.2.9_999 changelog that marked the game's first anniversary. The honest answer, as of this writing, is that no ending has been confirmed — and given that affection events unlock in tiers up to 5 with dedicated content at the top, it is entirely plausible that one exists but is not yet reachable in the public build.
Players have asked for Sylveon, Glaceon, Leafeon and Flareon, a female Vortigaunt, Toy Chica and other new characters; Japanese translation; an impregnation mechanic; a version with only male characters; more gallery and achievement tracking; and a real ending. None of these are implemented, and none appear on a published roadmap.